Featured Posts

Apple Store Employees Create a Raving FanApple Store Employees Create a Raving Fan It is not about being a Mac person or a Windows person. I know there are many personal preferences to that debate, but our decisions are based a lot on our history. This...

Readmore

An Apology Can Overcome the Most Difficult MistakesAn Apology Can Overcome the Most Difficult Mistakes Last week while I was in Chicago I received a call from my wife regarding an explanation of benefits (EOB) insurance form she received in the mail.  This is not something...

Readmore

Is Social Media A Fundamental Shift for Customer Service?Is Social Media A Fundamental Shift for Customer Service? As I am sitting here preparing for my keynote at the Call Center Summit in Orlando I keep thinking about this question.  I have seen a fascination with social media uses...

Readmore

When Life Gives You Lemons, Just Make Lemonade!When Life Gives You Lemons, Just Make Lemonade! "There is a lesson to be learned from the Lemonade Girl with the pretty blue eyes and hair that once curled.  You see, Alex lived by the words from which her foundation...

Readmore

Attention C-Suite: The Times They Are A-Changin'Attention C-Suite: The Times They Are A-Changin' The C-Suite needs to hear some words from Bob Dylan: Come gather 'round people Wherever you roam And admit that the waters Around you have grown And accept it that...

Readmore

Time to be Frank Rss

Tell A Story of Widgets and Whatchamacallits

Posted on : 01-05-2010 | By : Frank Eliason | In : Customer Service

2

I have been lucky to watch a lot of positive change at different companies.  Just to play a small part in that change can be very exciting, but it got me thinking: what generates change?  For years businesses have concentrated on data and numbers.  For most businesses the most important number is the bottom line.  I am not opposed to numbers, and I recognize for a company to survive the bottom line is extremely important.  This concentration on the numbers, sometimes has had an unintentional impact on the actual Customer experience.  Trust me, every leader I have ever worked with has understood the benefits of a long term Customer relationship, and they never intended to create a negative experience.  There are cultural barriers in business that have been created over the years, not just due to numbers, but in some cases the culture of generations ago.  No one ever wants to pass bad news up the chain of command.  Don’t you feel bad for the person bringing in a surprise for a quarterly with bad numbers?  Now that is a job I would never want!  In many companies the culture has not been to opt not to share bad information, or say no to something.  Sometimes they just sugar coat bad news.  The gen Y, or millennial generation is helping to change that because they do not play by those rules.

So here is what I think happens:

The CEO and other top leaders are reviewing the company quarterly reports.  The conversation is rather lengthy.  Early in the conversation the CEO says we really need to improve profit margins.  Later during that same conversation he notices that widgets have very nice profit margins.  This rightfully gets translated into we need to sell more widgets.  This makes its way through various leaders and now everyone is concentrated on selling widgets.  Marketing is placing widgets everywhere on the website.  Customer service was now asked to sell more widgets, which eventually translated to the supervisors and agents that they must sell widgets on every call.  The Customer is now being bombarded with offers for the widget everywhere they turn.  So even if they only need a Whatchamacallit, they were told they need a widget to go with it.  One of the Customer Service agents knows there is a problem with the widgets, and they have a high return rate.  The agent tells his supervisor that these widgets “suck”, but the supervisor does not recognize it as a problem and  fails to share with others.  Maybe the supervisor just didn’t want to listen!  It is not until further analysis of the numbers that this information turns up.  During this sales effort they also alienated Customers because they did not know they needed the widget, but finally gave in and purchased it.  They then returned it to only find the trouble with the next widget.  Now the Customer lost trust in the company.

Now, lets imagine instead of stating that the widgets “suck” the agent turned to the supervisor and said:

I would like to share the story of Sally.  Sally called looking for Whatchamacallit but instead we sold her Widgets that she did not need.  Sally had to wait a week to receive the Widgets, but when they finally arrived they were broken.  She then called us back and we sent a pick up authorization, which did not come to her until a week later.  She then returned the Widgets and we mailed her new Widgets, which were broken again.  So she just called for a new return authorization, so I tried to offer her a Whatchamacallit to help get her doohicky to fully work.  She told me forget about it, she is just getting a Whatchamacallit from Walmart because we just can’t get it right.  Sally was very frustrated with us.

Imagine this story made it to the CEO.  They probably didn’t intend to create this negative experience for Sally, and if they heard about it, they too would be as upset as Sally.  Connecting to Customers through stories are the real driver for change.  Stories come through on calls, emails, and through social media.

Your story could impact the bottom line!

Comments (2)

Frank it seems like your overall point is that companies need to spend more money on customer service. I’ve got a couple people in my life who work at call centers (Verizon). They are not well-paid, they’re not treated well, and there is no emphasis on actually fulfilling the customer’s true need. (Not necessarily the need they state on the phone. Sales types call it the “need behind the need.”)

Most illustrative of this is how popular the “I was a Comcast CSR”-type threads on Reddit, Consumerist, and so forth. They read like exposes on the seediest parts of town. You hit the nail on the head — stories from front-line CSRs need to make it out into the light and up the chain of command.

Great post!

Frank,

I think there is even more wrong with the company in the example you cite above. If its internal data indicates that widgets have a high profit margin even though there’s a high customer return rate, I would question the ability of their accounting department, among others. Does this company really know what makes them money? Maybe they’ve just been lucky.

LAF

Write a comment